University of St. Andrews Branded ‘Hostile’ Against Free Speech on Campus


The University of St. Andrews is ‘hostile’ towards free speech on campus, according to a recent report by Spiked Online. The report has cast doubt over the notion that a University campus is a location which allows students and staff to engage in free speech. The report suggests very few Universities in the United Kingdom actually actively promote freedom of speech on campus. Some, they suggest, actively block freedom of speech. In this article, we take a look at the report on Surrey.


Questions have been asked regarding freedom of speech on campuses at UK Universities


The report was the 2018 edition of Spiked Online‘s annual free speech rankings, with 115 Universities being ranked. The report examined any policies or actions that a University or Student Union employs, and analyses the threat each poses to freedom of speech on campus. These can include specific speakers being banned, censorship and other policies. The organisation subsequently rank each University using a traffic-light system. Red denotes the institution is ‘hostile to free speech’. Amber suggests it ‘chills free speech’, with Green suggesting the University has a ‘hands-off approach’ to free speech. Click here for a full explanation.




The study gives the University of St. Andrews a red rank. The study concludes that the University and Students’ Association ‘collectively create a hostile environment for free speech’. The University was given a red ranking – due to how it bans ‘transphobic material’ from the curriculum and restricts ‘offensive jokes’. The Association was given an amber rank – due to how it restricts ‘offensive sexual noises’. This averaged out as a red mark – and is a negative reaction to 2017 – when the University was rated amber. In 2015, it was green.


There have been a range of freedom of speech-related controversies around the United Kingdom


Looking at the overall conclusions – surprisingly only seven of the 115 institutions analysed were given a green rating. Among them were the University of Buckingham, Robert Gordon University, Trinity St. David, and the University of Winchester. No traditional, long-established University attained a green rating, while the vast majority of London-based institutions were ranked as red. 63 Universities in total were given a red ranking, with 45 Universities attaining an amber rating. It should be noted that some have disputed the accuracy and methodology of the report.




So a disappointing result for the University of St. Andrews – with the report having a negative outlook on freedom of speech on the institution’s campus. A University is somewhere that freedom of speech should be encouraged and harnessed to help students debate and achieve their potential. Yet it is equally important to create an environment where everyone feels comfortable. Sometimes it seems these two elements cannot function alongside one another, which is disappointing.



Thanks for reading. UniEel is on Facebook and Twitter.